Choosing the right Bizarre coffee beans can feel overwhelming, especially because we're kind of obsessed with them all. The truth is, the right coffee depends on how you prefer to drink it, what flavors you enjoy, and the kind of experience you want from your daily cup.
This guide breaks it down in the simplest way possible by answering the most common questions you should ask yourself when choosing coffee beans so you can find your perfect Bizarre Coffee match without overthinking it.
So...how do you choose the right coffee beans?
The ideal coffee beans for you depends on how you drink your coffee, the roast level you prefer, and the flavors you enjoy most. Medium roast coffee is the best starting point for most people because it’s smooth and balanced. Dark roasts are ideal for bold flavor and milk-based drinks, while light roasts highlight brighter, more complex notes.
First, What Kind of Coffee Drinker are You?
Do you prefer your coffee black or with a splash of milk?
If you like your coffee mostly black, you’ll probably gravitate toward coffees that are smooth, balanced, or a little brighter. Nothing too heavy or overpowering.
Here are the Bizarre Coffee options we recommend:
- Brazil Medium Roast – smooth, approachable, and an easy everyday coffee
- Ethiopia Light Roast – lighter, brighter, and great for slower sipping
- Rwanda Medium Roast – smooth, sweet and layered
Do you prefer lattes, cream, or sweet drinks?
If milk or sweetness is part of your routine, you’ll want a coffee that can hold its flavor and still shine through.
Our top Bizarre Coffee beans for milk-based drinks:
- Espresso Medium Roast – our go-to for lattes and espresso drinks
- Brazil Medium Roast – smooth and versatile with milk
- Jude’s Brew Dark Roast – bold, velvety, and great if you like a stronger cup
- Soulful Medium Roast – rich and comforting, especially in cozy drinks
What roast level should you choose?
Roast level plays a huge role in flavor, and choosing the right one can completely change your experience.
What’s the difference between light, medium, and dark roast coffee?
- Light roasts highlight brighter, more complex flavors and origin characteristics
- Medium roasts are balanced, smooth, and easy to love
- Dark roasts are bold, rich, and classic in flavor
If you’re unsure, medium roast is always a safe place to start.
I don’t like bitter coffee, what should I choose?
If bitterness isn’t your thing, you’ll want coffees that lean smooth and balanced rather than super dark.
Try these:
- Brazil Medium Roast – a crowd favorite for a reason
- Rwanda Medium Roast – clean and easy-drinking
- Espresso Medium Roast – smooth enough for drip, strong enough for milk
I like bold, strong coffee, what should I choose?
If you love a rich, classic coffee flavor and want something that feels cozy and grounding, darker roasts are the move.
Bold favorites:
- Jude’s Brew Dark Roast – velvety, sweet, and bold
- Tropics Dark Roast Blend – dark and rich with a smooth finish
- Soulful Medium Roast – comforting and full-bodied
- Mexico Dark Roast – bold without being overwhelming
What coffee beans are best for espresso and lattes at home?
You don’t need fancy equipment to make great coffee drinks—you just need beans that pair well with milk.
Top choices for espresso-style drinks:
- Espresso Medium Roast – designed for it (and used in our shops)
- Brazil Medium Roast – a smoother latte base
- Jude’s Brew Dark Roast – for a stronger, more intense drink
What if I want coffee without caffeine?
If you love the ritual but don’t want the buzz, decaf doesn’t mean boring.
Go with:
-
Decaf Medium Roast – smooth, flavorful, and perfect for afternoons or evenings
I’m new to Bizarre Coffee so what should I start with?
If this is your first time ordering, don’t overthink it.
Easy starting points:
- Brazil Medium Roast – balanced and approachable
- Espresso Medium Roast – versatile and shop-tested
- Jude’s Brew Dark Roast – bold but still smooth
If you want to explore more without committing to one bag, sample packs are the move.
Sample Packs Available
- The Classics Sample Pack – our most-loved staples
- The Cozy Sips Sample Pack – rich, comforting coffees
- The Light to Dark Sample Pack – a full flavor spectrum from bright to bold
And if you already have a roast in mind, all of our regular coffees are now available in 4oz sample sizes, making it easy to sample taste before you commit!
Still not sure which coffee is right for you?
Totally fair. We’re kind of obsessed with all of them too. The truth is, there’s no “wrong” pick here, just different vibes. Some days call for something smooth and easy like Brazil or Espresso, other days you might want to lean into a bolder cup like Jude’s Brew, Soulful, or Tropics. Coffee isn’t meant to be complicated, it's meant to bring a little spark of joy to your day.
